Introducing: “The Journey,” from In the Dark

More from Two Girls One Ghost All episodes →

1. 

   E850 · 1 Oct 2026 · 51 min

   Encounters x351 - Sleep Paralysis | Demons, Entities & Alternate Realities

   Sleep paralysis is terrifying, but what if the nightmare doesn’t end when you wake up? This week, we’re diving into chilling encounters with shadow figures, mysterious voices, sinister entities, cursed games, and a mind-bending journey through alternate realities. And if you’ve ever considered playing Red Door, Yellow Door, this might be the episode that changes your mind. Sleep paralysis experiences include: A recurring sleep paralysis demon appears to swallow the storyteller’s loved ones, only to disappear after a death occurs in the family. A terrifying sleep paralysis episode leads to a…

2. 

   E849 · 27 Sep 2026 · 1 hr 10 min

   Episode 392 - The Great Amherst Mystery | A True Poltergeist Horror Story

   An invisible force plunged a knife into Esther Cox’s back not once, but twice. And somehow, that was only one of the terrifying incidents surrounding the Great Amherst Mystery, a bizarre 1878 poltergeist case involving flying objects, unexplained fires, spirit communication, and an unseen entity seemingly determined to torment Esther. We’re diving into one of the most heavily documented hauntings in history, including the skeptics and witnesses who saw the strange activity firsthand. But what exactly was following Esther, and why did the haunting refuse to leave her alone? Watch the video…

3. 

   E848 · 24 Sep 2026 · 52 min

   Encounters x350 - Haunted Forests, Campgrounds & Appalachia

   We love a peaceful walk in the forest, but sometimes there’s more than wildlife lurking between the trees. We’re venturing into the woods where cryptids, spirits, strange entities, and unexplained phenomena wait in the darkness, and these listener stories make the great outdoors feel a whole lot creepier after sunset. Stories include: One listener encounters a terrifying, unnaturally tall deer-like creature in the Blue Ridge Mountains. A strange stick doll found after a tragedy at a campsite triggers a streak of bad luck. A skeptic hears a child laughing in the Mississippi woods and later…

4. 

   E847 · 20 Sep 2026 · 49 min

   Episode 391 - r/Paranormal Reddit Horror Stories with Alexis Linkletter & Crimes of Reddit

   Sabrina’s Crimes of Reddit co-host, Alexis Linkletter, is filling in for Corinne, and we are diving into some seriously spooky Reddit stories, and a lot of paranormal rabbit holes. We’re talking creepy childhood encounters, sleep paralysis experiences, a possible visit from a grandmother, and a story about a little ghost girl who broke a child’s arm…twice. And of course, Reddit leads us into a spiral about astral projection, the Gateway Tapes, declassified government experiments, déjà vu, reincarnation, and the possibility that our brains are only perceiving a tiny piece of what is actually…

5. 

   E846 · 17 Sep 2026 · 51 min

   Encounters x349 - True Tales of Alien Abductions & UFO Sightings from Listeners

   We’re going full extraterrestrial this week and it’s not even Sabrina’s birthday. We’ve got listener stories of UFO sightings, alien abductions, missing time, and animal activity that is seriously hard to explain. We’re left with one very unsettling question: what exactly happens during those moments we can’t remember? Close encounters include: A young woman wakes up surrounded by exposed nails and discovers three mysterious figures standing over her, along with a strange mark around her wrist. A meteor shower in the Black Hills takes a terrifying turn when several friends lose hours of time…

6. 

   E845 · 13 Sep 2026 · 55 min

   Episode 390 - Phone Calls from the Dead

   We’re answering the phone, but this time, the call might be coming from the other side. We’re diving into the eerie history of phone calls from the dead, including early attempts to build devices that could communicate with spirits, Thomas Edison’s mysterious “spirit phone,” and the strange patterns researchers have found in reported phantom calls. Then we get into the truly creepy stuff: personal experiences of voicemails from loved ones who have already died, calls from disconnected numbers, and messages that seem to arrive with a warning or final goodbye. Watch the video version here.…

7. 

   E844 · 10 Sep 2026 · 1 hr

   Encounters x348 - True Stories of Glitches in the Matrix | Haunted Appalachia, Cryptids & Time Slips

   This episode is a time loop…or maybe it’s just an annual topic. We’re once again diving into the weirdest corners of reality with glitches in the Matrix, time slips, inter-dimensional encounters, and a few experiences that make us question whether reality is as stable as we think it is. Glitches include: A trip to the White Cliffs of Dover takes an inter-dimensional turn when a National Trust ticket booth seemingly disappears, leaving behind only a mysterious parking ticket. A routine drive through Appalachia suddenly transports a mother 30 minutes away with virtually no time passing. A…

8. 

   E843 · 6 Sep 2026 · 1 hr 7 min

   Episode 389 - Haunted University of Georgia & Sorority Ghosts

   We’re heading back to school, but this campus has a few residents who never graduated. We’re exploring the University of Georgia, one of America’s most haunted college campuses, and digging into its 240+ years of ghosts, murders, tragic history, urban legends, and seriously creepy campus lore. Then we’re heading down Milledge Avenue, where haunted sorority houses come with reports of mysterious knocking, sobbing, shadow figures, objects moving on their own, and a piano that plays by itself. Plus, one helpful ghost might just have a thing for matchmaking. See the stunning Alpha Gamma Delta…

9. 

   E842 · 3 Sep 2026 · 59 min

   Encounters x347 - Real Paranormal Stories: Ghosts, Cryptids & Hauntings

   It’s a kitchen sink episode, and we’re throwing everything paranormal at you! We’ve got haunted houses, dark entities, paranormal games gone wrong, La Llorona, a possible dragon sighting, a porn-addicted ghost and more. Stories include: A haunted childhood home brings night terrors, sleep paralysis, two sinister black cats, and a ghost that repeatedly changes the TV to an inappropriate channel. A game of Red Door, Yellow Door in a haunted basement unleashes a terrifying smiling man who appears in dreams and seems to follow the players beyond the game. A childhood spent attending disturbing…

10. 

    E841 · 30 Aug 2026 · 1 hr 7 min

    Episode 388 - The Sky War of 1561 | Renaissance Era UFOs

    It’s Sabrina’s birthday, and to celebrate, we put on our tinfoil hats and dove into one of history's strangest mysteries: the Sky War of 1561. Hundreds of people claimed they watched strange objects battle across the skies over Nuremberg before disappearing without a trace. Was it a message from God, a rare atmospheric event, or one of the oldest recorded mass UFO sightings? Along the way, things get delightfully unhinged, complete with conspiracy theories, alien tangents, and the wonderfully chaotic energy that happens whenever we start talking about extraterrestrials. Watch the video…