Skip to content
Melo Podcasts Home
CategoriesLanguagesFollowing

Season 1, Episode 170 · Not For Everyone

170. We’re Taking A Break.

23 Apr 2026 · 44 min

Play episode WhatsApp Download

Episode notes

Today, an open and honest conversation between Jess and Caroline. (James Blunt’s song, “Goodbye My Lover,” is featured in The Office, Season 3, Episode 10, "A Benihana Christmas.")

Transcript

Read the transcript · about 7,160 words, follows along as you listen

Hello again and welcome back to another episode of Not for Everyone. A podcast hosted by a hater and a lover. A podcast hosted by two scientists who are not scientists. Never have been, never will be. A podcast hosted by me, Jess and the love of my life Caroline and podcast that has a pretty big announcement today, which is that we are taking a break. We're taking a break, Caroline. We're just say it with me, we're taking a. Break. We're taking a break. We're taking a break and we have things to say about it and I'm just trying to think where to start. We have never taken a significant break. The podcast has been going for 3 1/2 years or so and we've taken like a week or two off for Christmas. We've alternated weeks by doing solo episodes so that one of us could have a break while the other one still worked. So we've been going hard at this for a while and I think, you know, it's not our main thing.

We both have full time jobs, so that alone is like a lot of time energy. I personally, I think it's been clear, have been talking about being burnt out for the last few months. And so that's one of the inputs into this. But I also think we have been realizing over the last few months that we're not having as much fun with it anymore. And that was like the whole point. That was like the whole reason to start it, especially since it's like a side hobby thing for us. Like, if we're not having fun with the hobby, then what? Why, why?

And so the two of us talked about it over the last couple of weeks. And I think we were both feeling it and, like, afraid to be the one to say it. And Caroline sent me a voice memo. She's usually the first one to say the truth. And I was like, yeah, I relate to I, I agree. We're aligned. I relate like, I'm tired, I'm not having fun. And I wish I was, but I'm not. Yeah. And we could talk about more of the why, but let me just stop and see what you want to add.

So far, yeah, I don't even know what to say. Been thinking so much about what to say in this episode. I would know we both have we've been like talking about like how do we talk about this? And it feels like impossible that we will like, capture it correctly or like be able to like, properly do right by like the people who've supported us and like, like for many years and like been a really great part of this podcast and like do right by the parts that have been great. And like, do right by like, you're in my relationship to each other and also say things that are like honest here. And I also know that like whatever explanation we give in this episode for taking a break and yeah, for contacts, we're thinking of like several months, like maybe six months, while we like take time to kind of like collect ourselves and realign or figure out like what we're doing here. I know that like whatever we say in this episode is like the reason will be taken as like the whole reason or the finite reason or like the this is the set in stone reason. And, and the reasons feel like it's been impossible thinking how to like what is correct to

say here over the last couple weeks. Because it just feels like I can't capture every aspect of it. While also like expressing the gratitude I have for like the 3 1/2 years of doing this together and of having like the audience that we have had and the support we have had, while also like capturing the things that are like I'm struggling with. And in a way I feel like I'm for me at least the reason that it's like hard to all my anxiety about trying to like caption. The reason here in this episode is like why I need the pause. I felt like very part of it part for me is that I think I felt like very unsure and very anxious for like years here about how like what is the proper way to show up? I think I've like struggled with that maybe longer it sounds like than Jess has probably.

I would guess because I was already like had been like doing content longer before and I already have like damage from doing it and like self doubt and maybe self doubt in a way, in a way almost sometimes that I think just that you don't have like some. I think that maybe in a way you have like a sense of self that I like. I'm very fragile, I'm very weak and, and it's just been like many years of like in and out of like being unsure of like what is the right way to show up and, and then like together as a team, just. And I, I don't know if I should be talking to you or talking to the audience.

But like you and I have gone through so many different like iterations and strategies of like what we think this podcast is for and what we think the content is for and like who we're trying to serve. Like I feel like we're like trying to figure it out. And we've tried a lot of different things, which may be interesting to share with listeners. I know we talked about sharing some of our thinking and where it landed us, but I think ultimately it's, it's two things for me #1 I feel like I'm not sure what I should be doing on the podcast.

I'm not sure who it should be serving or how I should be serving or, or what my purpose should be. And I do really believe in having like clear purpose with content. Even listeners sometimes have commented like, oh, you could do episodes about this or you could come on and do this. And, and I think there's a lot of things we could do, but I personally just, I don't know, sometimes I think about like when other people like say, like, Oh, I really want to, you know, kids, sometimes they're like, oh, I really want to have a YouTube channel, but like, what should I make it about? And I'm like, oh, don't I, I personally don't believe that you should just like make a YouTube channel because you want to have a YouTube channel.

I think you should make a YouTube channel because there's like something you want to say or there's this thing you really love or these, they're these people you really want to connect with. And I think that's how I feel about content generally. And I think I started here, we started here with a pretty clear idea of like what we thought our purpose was. And then we've pivoted a few times and I don't know anymore. And I, and I don't feel certain who and how we should be serving.

And, and then I, I think ultimately I don't think that's a good way to make a podcast. I don't think it's just like we could make a podcast. We can make a podcast about like a lot of things. But like what is I, I think I do want to have more clarity on purpose and mission. And I think if you don't have those things, then it does start getting disappointing for people or messy for people or messy for us. And, and I'm, yeah. And I think I'm, it's been affecting me.

And I don't think I can like, I don't think I'm up to the challenge right now of like being affected in the way that it's. Yeah. Yeah, I, I mean, I agree that like it hasn't been affecting me in the same way for as long as you, but that has caught up to me in the last couple of months. And, you know, whatever it is about me where I think I'm quicker to say like, yeah, I don't, I don't have to like put myself through this. Like I think you've talked about like enduring to a fault, right?

Like that you've sometimes endured to a fault with different things that aren't making you feel good. And I think I have done that too. But I feel like I've, I've come to this place and I think a lot of it is like growth that I've actually had from the podcast and from our conversations. Like I, I'm like a a different version of myself than when we started in a way that I'm really proud of. And for both of us. For both of us, I really agree. Like I think that we, I think everything we've talked about here has like shaped me for the better and learning from you has shaped me for the better.

And anyway, I'm just at a point where like I'm much more able to quickly say that something's not working and like kind of set a boundary for myself. And so as soon as you voiced like, I've been feeling this way for a while, I was like, maybe I haven't been feeling that for as long. But yeah, even the taste of it that I'm getting like recently, I agree. And I don't I'm not in a space right now to endure it if I ever want to endure it. This, this battle of like what is energizing for us to come and talk about with each other every single week and to feel like there's purpose in putting it out into the world and also like the Venn diagram of that with what people are going to like and respond to and want more of. And like, I feel like at the beginning we had that a little more clear, or at least our purpose felt clear. And then the people who liked it came and stayed, and it resonated for a while.

But I also think a lot of that was like us sharing personally about ourselves. Like, the audience didn't know me at all. So I had tons that I could share. And even for you, they knew you from YouTube. But there's so much more behind what you show in an edited YouTube video that you were like, excited about or interested in. Curious about sharing in a more open free form, like conversational forum with another person. And so for both of us, I think it was like we are comfortable sharing about ourselves more than the average person, you know, like on a platform We that kind of intrigues us and we feel like we have something to say from those experiences that we've had. And it'll be interesting to like see how each of us share some of those experiences and beliefs and opinions and values and how we differ and how we talk about that and navigate it together. And like, that was kind of, I think the purpose at the beginning.

And then you get to a point where it's like, OK, this has been working for a while, but like, feel like I've said everything about my personal life that I am comfortable saying. And so then it's like, OK, well, what do we do? I still have like good advice and, you know, opinions that I think are interesting and worth talking about and views on the world that I think are worth sharing. And so let's try to get more of that out there. Let's try to maybe like respond to listeners and give more advice based on our experience and based on what we know as unprofessional people who are just like kind of showing up as whole humans and hopefully friends. And let's like do it that way.

And so for a while we pivoted from like personal sharing to more like listener based, let's get hot, take inputs, let's get what a dues. Let's think about like what are the deep dive episodes, like dating episode, career episode, family episode, like let's do it that way. And I think that worked for a while. I think also because like once, yeah, like I think we started sharing a lot personally and then they're just began to be natural places. I think in a healthy way that we, it didn't feel appropriate to share.

Like when we started the podcast, I was dating, you know, I, it wasn't, I didn't have like 1-1 intimate relationship and a person to like protect and even, you know, just in talking about dating, there were people who were affected. And I, I like learned pretty quickly I shouldn't really be talking about dating. That was a big deal. And then, you know, there's things with family that I wanted to express and share, but then like, they're also known.

And at a certain point that didn't feel very appropriate or fair. And yeah, so then it felt like, OK, well, we know some of our most popular episodes have always been the ones like kind of giving more retrospective advice to like, things we've already passed through phases, maybe breakups or starting your career or dating or things that were it's kind of more in the rear view. So it doesn't feel as exposed and personal and seems like people really value those. Those are always our biggest episodes. And so, yeah, we tried to lean into that for a while. That was our like explicit thinking. With that, go on.

And I feel like we've no that was like help helpful additional context. And I think we both Caroline more vocally and me in my own head, we're like got annoyed with ourselves at some point after like a year of doing it that. Way of giving advice. Of giving advice like I'm sick of hearing myself drone on thinking I know what these people should do. And obviously we try to show up to it with awareness that we don't know shit like humility about like we're just talking and doing our best and sharing what was worked for us.

And but it just got to a point where it's like, there's there's, I don't know, I don't feel good giving advice every week. I don't like listening to myself do that. It's like I know I'm annoyed with myself, even if other people, I think the audience was kind of liking it, but I didn't envision that as like how I would spend week after week on this podcast when we first started. It's like never been my intention to be an advice column. So I don't know if you have more to add about that.

Oh yeah, giving advice trigger triggers myself hatred so strongly. Like I mean, I for I guess this is ridiculous to say, but like I all at once think that like on the topics we choose, we chose to give advice on. It's not all things I don't think I have good advice on. All things. We've skipped things that we're like, I don't know what to do with that or like I'm actively struggling with that thing. But for the areas that we've like felt confident enough to like share a perspective on, I actually feel like pretty confident about like your and my advice in those areas. That's why we chose those specific areas and not others. I I've like, I think we have good advice and also it triggers myself hatred so hard to hear myself giving advice or like thinking I know anything about someone else's life or like telling them what to do.

It's like ironically in my private life, like in my personal growth, I am one of the biggest things I'm working on is like not trying to influence other people's life is not trying to tell people how to live or what to do or speak with judgement or like direction and like to like help people. If if I do anything, it's like to help people navigate life on their own, not to be telling them what to do unless they specifically ask. But it's like it's so at odds with it makes me feel, it really makes me hate myself that it's a very, very weird feeling for me. But that feels hard.

And then and then it also feels so self serious that I think we are both craving like, all right, we can't just be an advice podcast, even if people like that are valid, that to some degree, it does get very heavy. It's very self serious. It can feel very self important. It doesn't make me like myself. And so why don't we? Maybe we can like use listener write insurance more. It's kind of like a jumping off point, a conversation starter. And we can like maybe talk about that, but we can spiral into tangents. We can talk about things that do come back to us and feel personal again and connected, but like, maybe, yeah, take tangents off of that.

So it's not just advice, but it can be personal again. And I feel like that's like where we pivoted. That was like our third pivot maybe. And it felt risky. Like I think it felt for a little while more energizing to us of like, oh, OK, like we can touch on the advice stuff that's been resonating with the audience, but we can also veer off into like, exploring stuff about ourselves or telling this other story and moving on from the conversation or whatever. And it felt like we we could do both. Like, OK, maybe this idea makes it so we can do both. We can do the advice that we have noticed that the audience likes a lot and we can do more of the like banter and self exploration and self sharing and whatever in like a, a guided way, like a more structured way.

Yeah. But I think even then, I don't know, like it's very sensitive like to bounce off of. Someone else's life experience. Someone else's life experience and a write in that they've been vulnerable to share. Like it's sensitive and we don't that tone is really hard to strike and get right to do both of those things. And so again, it felt like this isn't working if we've tried all of these three different, you know, approaches, not to mention other approaches sprinkled in between of like just sillier episodes and hot takes and like talking about pop culture and doing things that are impersonal to anyone that are more just like bippity bops. I don't think I could do that every single week. Like there's not always something to bippity bop about in pop culture that really gets me going. Like Taylor, Frankie, Paul, you know, which we've talked about like 4 times.

So it just leaves me at least in a place where I'm like, I don't know where to go. And, and I don't think I can figure that out while doing it. Like I think that's a big reason for wanting a long break for me is. It's like I'm too close to it and like we haven't stepped back. And plus everything else in life, I don't have a lot of space outside of the podcast to really think about the podcast. Like I'm doing work and I'm getting here, like in between calls and I'm coming back.

And so there's just not a lot of like creative space, like freedom and like time away from it to say like, oh, it, it might feel good to do this or we haven't tried this or actually even more than any of those tactical things. I want to return again to like, what's even the purpose to what you said originally? Like before we get tactical about what the episodes should be and what's the format and is it advice or is it personal sharing or is it funny or is it something else? It's like step back and think about what even is the goal 'cause I think the goal has changed for both of us, but we don't quite know what it is.

We just know it's not the same. And there's kind of like goals for what we want to. There's like for me, there's like 2 categories of goals. There's what we want to share and like the space that we create on the podcast and the content. And then there's also the overarching like where do we even want this to go? Because at the beginning, I've been vocal and like on my other podcast Peeking, I've talked a lot about I, my dream at the beginning of this was can we get it to a place where we've grown it and we can make a living off of it?

And I can leave my corporate job and like do this thing that I love. And I don't know if I want that anymore. And I've been realizing that over the last year or so. Like, that was very clearly my personal dream outcome from this at the start, and I wouldn't have known if I wanted that or not if I hadn't like tried and tested it and seen. So I'm so grateful to have had the opportunity to do this, to do it with you, to have an audience that's been stuck with us through all these different versions. And like, let us be ourselves at least most of the time. And also like, as we did that over the course of the 3 1/2 years, I think at some point I started to realize, like, this is still, maybe there's still something here, but I don't actually know if I would want this to be my full time. And if I don't want it to be that, that's OK. But then what do I want it to be? And I haven't answered that question. And I don't have space to figure out the answer to that question. And that's part of what in addition to like what's the content, that's part of what I personally want to spend a lot of time figuring out is like,

what's the overarching goal in terms of like my career aspirations or my like dream job, passion project, side hustle. But like, do I even want that anymore or is it something else? I don't know. And I've been kind of tossing that around in my head for at least the last, yeah, almost a year probably. Like since last summer, I would say I've been actively chewing on that question. And it's a hard question to answer because it involves letting go of what was once a dream. Even if it's right to let go of it. I that's hard.

So I can't, I can't do it while we're also showing up every week tired and not sure what to do and kind of feeling like it's not as fun anymore. Like I can't. I can't figure it all out at the same time without a break. Is there more you feel comfortable saying about like what changed for you that you're like, oh, I don't like the more you learned that you're like, oh, I don't know if I want this to be something I quit my job for and do full time maybe.

I don't know if there's more you can say publicly. I think I've said it a little bit, but it's worth exploring, which is like the way that you talked about how this has been hard for you for much longer than it has been for me. And a lot of that to do with the fact that your whole career is YouTube and is on the Internet and is involved with like getting outside feedback and having to like tailor how you show up accordingly. And it triggers yourself hatred.

And I mean, you're amazingly talented at what you do. So I hope that never is a reason for you to stop. Like I want to always be a person that's there to help you keep going and push through those moments because of how much I think what you do is so special. But at the same time, when I think about myself, like putting myself in in that type of setup, or rather when I think about why you perceive me to be a little bit more like self assured in this way or like, you know, just like the sense of self that you perceive in me in this way. I think a lot of it does have to do with the fact that I have something totally separate from this going on where if this doesn't work, I don't have the threat of the other thing not working because it's a corporate nine to five job where I make a paycheck.

And like, they don't care. They don't care. They don't see the comments on my podcast. They don't know if it's successful or not. It's not relevant. And I think that having that as like an anchor is actually helpful in keeping me true to myself here, which then begs the question of like, OK, if that's helpful for me, like, what then? What am I doing here? Because initially what I was doing here was pursuing a different career path. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that makes sense.

And so, yeah, it's like I don't have to be pursuing a different career path here. It could be a hobby, it could be a passion project, There's lots of configurations. I could leave my 9 to 5 corporate job and do more like freelance self-employed work and then also do something like this. And I don't know how I feel about that, but like that's a possibility. There's just like a lot of ways I could set it up. But I, I do feel like I need for me to have a different thing, which you have a different thing, but it's so closely intertwined that like it's the same thing.

It's a different thing and it's the same thing. And, and I think that's just what I've connected the dots on recently is like, I don't think I could. I think the self assuredness that you see in me, I think I would crumble just the same if my setup was different. You know, I don't think that's a flaw in you. I think that's the environment. Could be a combo, could be both or that, but it's funny. Yeah. I feel like even though we both have like different jobs that support us outside this podcast, like I think my reasons feel like kind of similar. Like in a way when I to me, when we were starting the podcast, I think my original goals were a few. I was like 1 I wanted to have and and another I wanted to add in a different like work project or work energy with someone else.

I didn't want to do anything else alone. I'm just alone all the time talking to a fucking camera. And I was like, I would I did not want to do like a podcast alone or on anything alone. I wanted to do it with like someone who gives me energy. That's my Princess Jess. I wanted and I, I secondly, I wanted a place where I could feel less edited, less restricted than I do on my YouTube main channel, where I could just kind of be more free flowing. And thirdly, I thought it would be a good business idea to have like a backup business kind of as like, you know, well, YouTube will probably come to an end eventually. Might as well start building this other thing can kind of build them in tandem.

And maybe eventually the podcast will be the main thing. And I think now 3 1/2 years later, we know it's a really hard business. Like we don't really make money from this business. I think it's better to think of it as a hobby. It's not really, it's not going to be something that replaces or like even break like usually breaks even. And I, it has become, I think largely through my own fault, like a place where I actually feel more restricted than I do on my main channel.

I feel more unsure of how to show up and I feel more like I'm struggling personally. And in my head I think a lot more. So those are both gone. And then the one thing that has remained is that like, like I said to you, the hardest part of leading the podcast is like you, like you of those three things have been the thing that delivered and that has been really special. And like our relationship has like, like, I know we've both like changed as individuals and like our like friendship is like, it's been so special and unique.

Not only has it deepened, but it's like different than like anything I've done with anybody and been like challenging in ways that like we pushed through together and like has been like really beautiful. And you've been obviously you're like the best business partner I could think of. So like, of those three things, I went into one, one remains, but yeah. But that's what I'll miss the most. Yeah, that's not me. Sad. Yeah, and scary. It's like, obviously our friendship still exists and like I am, I want to always invest in that, but it's really rare to have like a built in hour long session with one of your friends every week. And so like just the thought of like, we're not going to talk like that every week, especially when I think about the earlier days of the podcast when we were sharing a lot more. Personally and like.

We were getting to know each other as adults because we. Yeah. We have a history. We we have a lot of trust just from like how long we've known each other, but we didn't know a lot about each other as adults and our adult lives. And like that, I feel like we built such a foundation of like, you really know me in a way that in a way that no one else does. And I think part of that too is navigating the behind the scenes harder things we've had to deal with or like navigating have it trying to have a business together and like strategy and like, it's such a layered type of relationship that I, I don't have with anyone else and I can't imagine having. I couldn't even explain to somebody else. I couldn't even like just explain all the like, what it's been like to figure it out together. Yeah, it's like really the biggest gift and the biggest thing I'll miss.

And I hope that we find a way to do it again or do it more. But yeah, I just wanted to echo that. Like I I can't describe what our relationship is to me other than it's like 1 of 1, you know? Yeah, I agree. I think the part that made me like, I thought, well, I did say this to you and I'll say on the podcast, something I realized in recent months is like my favorite parts of our conversation each week are before we press record. Because usually we sit down, we get on here, we get on Zoom together and we like say all the things that are on our mind, private things, messy things, ugly things, things that involve other people, that things that can't be aired, everything that's live and raw. And like that's my favorite part of the conversation. And then we say, OK, enough of that. Are you ready to hit record?

And then we start the conversation that can be aired. And so on one hand, I'm like, I have that same fear of like, it's nice to have something on the calendar each week. And I think we're going to have to work to like make sure we keep it up. And also, I don't even know how to say it, but like it, it feels like it's harder to have it on the podcast. And my hesitation around saying that is because I'm, I'm I'm all at once trying to like give listeners, the listeners who like care and have been supportive. I'm like trying, I know we're both trying to like give them a satisfactory like understanding of like why this is pausing right now without while also like being grateful to them for the support they've given and like they've done no one's done anything wrong.

When I say like it's hard to know how to show up on the podcast or it's hard for us to like have our connection on the podcast after we have record after we hit record. I think it's just we're struggling with the reality of, like, the Internet and the reality of, like, doing this bizarre thing that is like sharing your thoughts, sharing your private thoughts, like, it's a weird thing to do. Yeah. So I'm like, it feels hard to know like. It feels hard to know the lines.

Yes, and that's the whole thing. That's the whole issue. That's that's the whole reason we're pausing is like it feels hard to know, like how to say the thing that is true while also being I don't know. Well, I think the thing that has united us this whole time is that we feel really strongly about saying the truth like that. We value honesty, and I think that was part of what we anchored around when we started the podcast. And then over time, it feels like there's less space for that or like we have gotten in our heads about like, how honest can I really be or how much should I really share?

And even if there's no change, like even if it's imagined, which I don't think it is, but even if it is just that feeling alone, like sits in the back of our brains while we record, we're, we're not able to show up as authentically and honestly as we want to, as we value like as we meant to, as maybe we did previously. I think we still, we do our best to push ourselves through that, but it's scary. And I think that's like one of the biggest things to figure out in returning to the podcast. I feel like we're talking about it like it's over and I don't know what it is like.

It's a long pause and we need to figure out what is next. And I hope there's more. And I think we just can't even fathom like what that is. So many things about how we started have changed and in this new landscape of like who we are now, how much we've already shared up to this point, how many more people are paying attention now, the scale that your channel has gotten to over this time, like all of these different aspects of it just make it like the landscape is different now. And I don't know what there's space for at this moment. I hope there's space for something from us together, but I can't even figure out what that is. So like it is a pause and we think about six months is right to take a good chunk of time away. But if that's on the other side of that, like if we don't figure it out, it could be longer, it could be it. I hope, yeah, we're aiming to do a check in in six months. I think that's what we decided.

Yeah, yeah. So I just want to be clear about what they should expect. And unfortunately, I can't be that clear about it because we don't even know. I know, but. I can't even tell if people care. I'm like, I feel This is why once again, I feel so in my head, I'm like, at what? I know at one point I was like, Oh, some people are might be really upset. Some people have supported us for so long and love the podcast and are so good to us. And then at some point during this conversation, I was like, they're probably thinking we're so dramatic and they're probably thinking like, how can they be so like they're grieving this and La La. And it's like even in doing this, I, I have there's so many voices and they all contradict each other and both of them make me hate me and I don't it's like I even in like trying to talk about it.

I feel like very I'm in a very bad place in my head. Yeah, yeah. So it's a box. It's a box. And we don't know where the walls are. I don't know if anyone cares or if people care so much and they're going to be mad. It's like, how can I have no idea? How can I not know? I don't really know either, but I will say this. I've talked about when my favorite podcast ended and like that was almost a year ago. No, it was probably over a year ago. I don't know. I still, I still miss it every day and I still go back and listen to old episodes just for like comfort. And I don't want to be have a big head and be like, people are going to be obsessed with this podcast where people are obsessed with this podcast in the same way I was obsessed with Nikki Glaser, a famous comedians podcast. But I maybe messages from people who really write the most, the most generous kind, like appreciative, thoughtful notes to us.

And whether that's five people or the whole audience or something in between, I'm talking to those people. Like I, I think those people are right here with us in terms of like the, the gravity of this, I guess, and. Yeah, I ran into, I texted you. I ran into a listener yesterday in Chicago, and she was really sweet. She was like, I listened to your podcast. I just wanted to let you know. And I was like, I think I was weird. If you're out there, Rebecca, I think I was weird. I was like, I was like, we are recording this episode tomorrow about taking this break.

And here I am meeting sweet Rebecca. And I don't know how to be. She doesn't know yet. And I have this like secret in my head and like, I don't like, I don't know the level of listener that she is like. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's a funny thing, you know. Like this, is she just being like, oh, yeah, what? I just listen to it. Or is she being like, no, this, this means a lot to me. And she's going to be one of the ones that's really upset tomorrow. And she doesn't even know how upset she's going to be.

And I was like, I have to thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you. So much I have to go. It's but that, you know, that's part of this. And I think we need a break from that over thinking too. Like there are so many, there's so many reasons why this came together and we both were like, yes, this is the right decision. And I think we were really considered in how we approached it and we've talked about it a lot and like it is the right decision, even though we cried and even though we don't know what's next, like we know it's right at this time. And we appreciate you all for sticking with us and getting it now.

And I, I hope, I hope to talk to you more soon. I don't know. Oh, I did want to do something else though. OK this is how I want to send us off. OK, so picture picture. Can I close my eyes? Episode of The Office, Yeah. OK. The episode of The Office in season 2 or 3 when Michael is heartbroken about his breakup with Carol. She went to Sandals Jamaica with like, somebody else or something. And he like, Oh, no, she went on like a ski trip with somebody new and she like, with her kids. And he Photoshopped himself into the photo because he was mourning their breakup.

And somebody walked into his office while he was playing a song, 15 second clip of a song on repeat because he didn't want to buy the song on iTunes. So he was just playing this 15 seconds over and over again. And it's song by James Blunt. And it goes, goodbye, my lover. Goodbye, my friend. You have been the one. You have been the one for me. And then he plays it again. Touch my heart and touch my soul. That's going to make me cry because you actually have an amazing James Blunt esque voice.

That's like one of my most thought of scenes from The Office ever. And when we were voice memoing about this decision, it just like came to my soul. I was. Playing. Yeah. And I wrote it down and I was like, this is what I'm going to sing to her. This is what I'm going to sing to her. And do a full do a full verse without me interrupting. I don't know more than that because that's the 15 seconds that he. That's the whole song. That's the whole song. Goodbye, my lover.

And like Michael's kind of like singing along to it very meekly and his eyes are watering and I think Jim walks in. It's just I think I'm going to watch that tonight. I recommend it to everyone. I'll put the episode of The Office that it is in the description. I'll call you tonight. We can watch some of it together. Cute. Let's do it. OK, Love you. I love you. Good luck. To us, we love you guys.

Transcript supplied by the publisher with the episode.

Podcast

Not For Everyone

Not For Everyone · Health · English

Not for Everyone is a podcast hosted by a hater (Caroline Winkler) and a lover (Jess DeBakey). We're just two sweet kooks getting carried away being ourselves, waxing poetic on every topic we care too much about. Come for the humor, stay for the honesty. We know we’re not for everyone, but we bet we

More from Not For Everyone All episodes →

  1. S1 · E169 · 16 Apr 2026 · 55 min

    169. Our Current Content Diet | Books, Bravo, and Brain Rot

    This episode is sponsored by Betterhelp. When life feels overwhelming, therapy can help. Sign up and get 10% off at BetterHelp.com/notforeveryone. ___ Hey! Hi! Today a passing comment about pediatricians leads to a wide-ranging discussion about the things we read, watch, and obsess over. Jess and Caroline explore an assortment of interests, including the evolving experience of childhood and their personal relationships to learning. Then they go deep on such admittedly shallow fare as The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, Traitors, and Temptation Island. Would you ever go on a reality TV show?…

  2. S1 · E168 · 9 Apr 2026 · 55 min

    168. Is This the Most Confusing Breakup Ever? + The Paradox of Spontaneity

    This episode is sponsored by Factor. Head to Factormeals.com/NOTFOREVERYONE50OFF and use code notforeveryone50off to get 50% off and free daily greens per box, with new subscription only, while supplies last until 9/27/2026. See website for more details. This episode is sponsored by Zocdoc. Stop putting off those doctors appointments and go to Zocdoc.com/NOTFOREVERYONE to find and instantly book a doctor you love today. ___ Hi boos! Today Jess and Caroline counsel a Kook University student who is looking for guidance on a recent breakup that went, possibly, too well. These fellow eighth year…

  3. S1 · E167 · 2 Apr 2026 · 58 min

    167. These Dating Dilemmas Made Us Feel Old (But You’re Probably Overthinking It)

    This episode is sponsored by Skims. Shop our favorite bras and underwear at SKIMS.com/notforeveryone . After you place your order, be sure to let them know we sent you! Select "podcast" in the survey and be sure to select our show in the dropdown menu that follows. #skimspartner ___ Hello! Hello! Welcome back to the “girl science” lab. Today’s first experiment, i.e. whatado, involves a cat, a crush, and the tough questions that come up when confronting loss. Jess sorts through her own full-body hater reaction, while Caroline explains how the whole world would be better if we all could just…

  4. S1 · E166 · 26 Mar 2026 · 1 hr 5 min

    166. Office Crushes, Toxic Jobs, and the Taylor Frankie Paul of It All

    This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Your emotional wellbeing matters. Find support and feel lighter in therapy. Sign up and get 10% off at BetterHelp.com/NOTFOREVERYONE . ___ Welcome back to class, babies! Your favorite professors have two whatados on the syllabus today, so take notes! First up, a Kook University student wonders if fantasizing about someone other than your beloved is on the spectrum of normal. In response, Jess and Caroline explore the life-giving force of mutual attraction and the purity of orgasms. Another pupil seeks out guidance on how to deal with the stark…

  5. S1 · E165 · 19 Mar 2026 · 1 hr 2 min

    165. Friends Who Never Host, Overbearing Parents, and Miley Cyrus | WHATADO

    This episode is sponsored by HelloFresh. Go to HelloFresh.com/NOTFOREVERYONE10FM to get 10 free meals + a FREE Zwilling Knife (a $144.99 value) on your third box. Offer valid while supplies last. Free meals applied as discount on first box. New subscribers only. Varies by plan. ___ Welcome babies and gentlemen! Your esteemed scientists test out some new theories and theorems this week as they tackle two whatados (and the legit challenge of reading aloud). First up, a potluck predicament in South Africa leads to a discussion about social faux pas and the potential cost of speaking up, even…

Take it with you

The Melo app keeps playing with the screen off, works in the car and on your watch, wakes you to your station, and browses the whole catalogue offline. Free, no ads, no account.

Get it on Google Play